Quote
Ok. I would defintely like to hear your opinion on this. If you had a high quality video in mxf, avi, or and you wanted to put it into power director or color director, what codec would you use aside from Pro Res that would preserve good quality? The avi container would have Grassvalley Canopus HQ codec. The MXF video codec is DV
My view, if one wants something that has reasonable quality and an excellent chance of producing correctly with PD when finished editing, i.e. no skips, no audio glitches, no hangs, no blocky video, no video tears, no audio/video sync issues, no random skipped frames, on and on, PD works best with a timeline of consistency with all basic MPEG, H.264 or H.265 with constant framerate and near constant bitrate. Anything else, simply adds more risk for issues, maybe not encountered in a 30 sec flick, but become hurdles in a 120 min production.
Also keep in mind, ProRes and MXF containers were both recently added import formats, only since PD18, it will take time to become productionized via user feedback. One such user stumped at any attention given to provide proper MXF audio support in the release,
https://forum.cyberlink.com/forum/posts/list/83622.page#post_box_345376 and providing additional suggestions here
https://forum.cyberlink.com/forum/posts/list/40/83388.page#post_box_345601 .
Additionally, PD has no output support for ProRes or MXF or high-end quality 10-Bit 4:2:2 so one ultimately has to produce to basic MPEG, H.264 or H.265 anyhow.
Jeff