Hi tomasc,
You're right, I produced quite decent quality Blu-Ray discs but was stymied by a menu bug in PD9. I upgraded to PD13 on the basis that it would allow me to create a disc without a root menu which got around that problem but introduced a new one whereby when played on a player the buttons appeared in a different place than when viewed in the preview screen.
I have now managed to resolve the quality issue with this latest project. I did what I was suggesting in my previous post, i.e. I pre-produced each title separately to a file in the Produce module using H.264AVC encoding which is the same as the camcorder source files. I used SVRT and unchecked hardware encoding, so theoretically most of the footage should have been passed through without re-encoding and any that needed it used the CPU. I then imported the resulting .M2TS files into the Create Disc module, authored and burned to a .ISO file and then burned that to a BD-RE disc using ImgBurn.
I can't remember if I used hardware encoding in Create Disc for my previous BD's but I know I didn't pre-produce the projects to .M2TS in this way.
An obvious advantage of creating the .ISO file is that if the test disc is satisfactory I can then use the file to make a permanent copy on a non-rewriteable disc without having to re-author, thus knowing that the permanent copy should burn successfully and be exactly the same. I know I did this with my previous discs as I needed to make a number of identical copies.
Using this production path the results are satisfactory, perhaps not quite as good as HDTV if you look really closely but perfectly acceptable, so this is the method I shall be using from now on.
However there is no getting away from the fact that this is a workaround due to problems in the Power Director software on my system. It had no problem producing to a file using H.264 with CPU encoding in the Produce module yet for some reason it repeatedly crashed whilst trying to do this within the Create Disc module. The only difference in this latest project is it's total size - about 17GB. The earlier projects were much smaller. Maybe this has some bearing on the problem but PD ought to be able to cope up to the ful 25GB of a Blu-Ray disc.
As I've remarked before I think the Cyberlink engineers time could be better spent sorting out some of the long-standing and widely-reported issues rather than adding "90+ Amazing new effects"!
Regards,
Mike
Home-build system:
Intel Core i5 Quad Core 3.3GHz, 2 x 4GB DDR3 1333MHz,
Asus Nvidia GT440 1GB, 2 x Western Digital WD10EARS 1TB, 1 x Seagate ST1000DM010 1TB,
Windows 7 Prof 64-bit, PD 9 Ultra 64, PD 13 Ultimate 64