- link disabled -
Footage is unedited apart from the colour corrections made.
After a full week of editing with this software (And the whole PD11 Suite) my final opinion is that the biggest advantage of ColorDirector is also its biggest flaw - its oversimplified controls. I admit that I will probably become more skilled at using ColorDirector but I doubt the results will vary much.
Pros:
- Quick and easy workflow
- Keyframes
- Easy controls (also its biggest drawback)
- In line editing (colour grading done on the time-line in PowerDirector 11)
- Fairly decent results
Cons:
- No histogram. This means editing is done based on 'what the eye sees' and can lead to poor/mismatching results.
- No colour curve adjustments (replaced by sliders which are not as accurate). This is a big let down for anyone who is used to working with curves when making these adjustments. This means advanced editing also becomes next to impossible. For example: When using custom in camera colour profiles (flat profiles) which is becoming a very popular trend, you usually need to use look-up tables (usually in the shape of a S-curve LUT curve) for accurate results which requires colour curves. It is also incredibly hard to get satisfying results in terms of the overall contrast with the provided slider compared to using the traditional curves.
I could easily write a whole article as a review and elaborate even more but thought I'd keep this simple and I hope this clip is of some value to others interested in purchasing this software.
UPDATE
Can the moderator please delete this thread as the link no longer works?
Thanks
This message was edited 2 times. Last update was at Oct 20. 2012 08:36
NVIDIA GeForce GT 525M
64 Bit Operating System
16GB RAM
Spyder3