To summarize the issue: When previewing, clips in AVCHD and MP4 format display fine after changing the TV Format from "NTCS (60 FPS)" to "NTCS (30 FPS)". However, for .MOV clips... Even though they preview fine in my other video editor, high bit rate .MOV clips do NOT preview properly in PD11. They stutter, play slowly and erratically, and/or play at a very low resolution.
For more details, skip down to the substantive posts starting with the post dated: "23/06/2013 21:37:21".
Thanks,
Dan.
----------------------------------
Well much has happened... After reporting PD11 issues in another thread (now resolved) where James1 and Eugen157 helped me, I created a new thread here at the recommendation of BarryTheCrab.
Now that the basic issues are cleared up, <another product> and PD11 seem to be good options for me, but I don't want to the exorbitant <another product> subscription fees. Both produce good quality video and both can add enhancements like titles, cross fades, etc. Here are the same clips in three formats (AVCHD, MP4, and MOV) post processed in <another product> and PD11:
Other than the obvious differences in titles, I see no difference in the video produced. That said, I see some issues:
Difficulty in creating titles for the slides - In <another product>, I ran into trouble creating titles. I haven't created titles in this version, so it may be the issue. On the PD11 side, it was easier and faster to create the titles, but I didn't like the glitzy graphics. Again, there may be a simple way of creating simple titles, but in my "noobness", I missed that. I need to read/watch some tutorials.
PD11 seems to be a bit slower overall than <another product> - In <another product> , when you move the timeline slider, the reaction is instantaneous - totally real time. In PD11, there is perceptible lag in the response time. There may be a way to resolve this, but it's not a huge issue in any case. I see other posts about video drivers, etc. I need to check that out.
However...
A more significant issue that I'd like to resolve is that the PD11 preview window shows a lower level resolution while the <another product> window is crystal clear. Screen shots of each are attached. The preview window was set to 75% zoom and HD/Full resolution. Any way to improve this in PD?
Thanks,
Dan.
p.s. My system's DXDiag is attached (the 64 bit version with my name in the file name) for reference.
Filename | ScreenShotPowerDirector.jpg |
|
Description | ||
Filesize |
51 Kbytes
|
|
Downloaded: | 304 time(s) |
Filename | ScreenShotPremiere.jpg |
|
Description | ||
Filesize |
55 Kbytes
|
|
Downloaded: | 290 time(s) |
Filename | DanClark64DxDiag.txt |
|
Description | ||
Filesize |
53 Kbytes
|
|
Downloaded: | 587 time(s) |
This message was edited 11 times. Last update was at Jun 25. 2013 11:43
PC: Win7/64, 32Gb memory, SSD sys disk, Raid 5 data disk, Raid 0 production disk.