Hi,
First post as a new user of PD10
I started with Pinnacle Studio (it came with the capture/tv card), didn't much like it (not saying that there was anything wrong with it - it just didn't 'click' for me) then moved to Adobe Premiere Elements. Forum rules say that we don't discuss/compare competing products I see, so I'll not go into the gory details of working with Premiere apart from suggesting to anyone that is considering it that they search the Adobe user forums for variations on 'Grey Screen of Death'
Anyway, after the divorce from Adobe, I spent a few weeks reading up and deciding between PD, Corel and Sony. As my main workflow at the moment is conversion of old (late 80's) VHS, PD seemed the best fit.
So far, I think I made the right choice. PD is a dream to use - it's simple and intuitive. All of the basic NLE functions are easily accessible with plenty of the more advanced stuff easily available without cluttering up and confusing the UI. It's quick and the enhancement and image stabilisation tools are very capable (essential for old video filmed on a full-format VHS camera that was about the size of a small briefcase).
Downsides?
I'm not thrilled by PD's capture performance - but that's not a problem as the Pinnacle PVR software that came with the card makes a good job of this side of things, so I've not bothered to experiment too much with settings.
The only big downside for me is the Cyberlink EULA - this really shows the difference in heritage between a product like Premiere that comes from a mature company at the top end of town and PD that comes from the other side of the tracks (no offence intended to Cyberlink - they've made a product that can compete and even beat one of the biggest, most powerful players in the field - they just need to grow up a bit on the legal side). The two killers for me that might, one day, drive me back to Adobe are the Single Installation rule - I expect to be able to install an application on both my desktop and laptop on the same licence providing that they are not used at the same time - if Microsoft and Adobe offer this, anyone can. The second EULA issue is the one of 'No commercial use' Why not? There is no explanation of what 'commercial use' means - I'm choosing to believe that it relates to commercial video production (weddings etc where the user charges for production) rather than the production of the odd promo for my (non-video related) trade-stand at agricultural shows - if that's not the case then it's back to the drawing-board.
This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at Jan 29. 2012 19:07