KTskier: Welcome to the PD11 forum. I suspect that your BD player does not support the format(s) you have selected. I had the same problem with a commercial BD (Strike Back - Project Dawn). I checked it out:
http://www.avsforum.com/t/1117941/list-of-blu-ray-movies-authored-in-1080i50
I then checked with Sony and because this commercial BD transcodes (or whatever they call it - I am not, by ANY means, a guru) at 50 fps, my Sony S550 would not play it, but PowerDVD 10 plays it just fine. Sony has no plans to issue a compatible BD player for the North American market, so they told me.
I note that your burn profiles are mixing interlaced with progressive scanning, and I am wondering about your frame rate and profile. I have successfully burned BDs in PD11 using the H.264 AVC 1920x1080 60i profile and they do play just fine on my Sony.
I am wondering if PD11 is converting your 24 FPS to a 50 FPS when it transcodes, or whatever it is called. In any event, DON'T take my word for it. I am a complete NEWBIE when it comes to all of this, but your comments that the BDs play in PowerDVD 9.5, but not on your BD player, brought to my old and decrepit mind, my recent experience with that commercial BD.
Hope this was of some limited help, and hopefully someone who DOES know what they are talking about, will chime in and point you in the right direction. Have a great day.
Regards,
-Phil
Windows 10 Pro x64
Dell XPS 8930
Intel CoreT i7 (4.6 GHz)
32 GB DDR4-2666 RAM
1 TB PCIe -x4 SSD
NVIDIA GeForce RTX 2060
PD14 Ultimate x64, 4207
CD4 Ultra and AD6 Ultra
Bleeping Computer Malware Response Instructor